TEST TRACK ARRIVAL BOARD MAINTENANCE OF WAY BOOMER TRAIL CRAFTSMAN CLASSICS OPERATIONS
HOME BOOK DEPOT BACK ISSUES TIMETABLE COMPANY STORE CARSTENS CONTACT US
PRODUCT REVIEWS
ADVERTISERS

A2Z CNC

Aero-Car Hobby Lubricants

A-Line

Accucraft

Accurail

Adair Shops

Albion Software

American Model Builders

American Models

Amherst Railway Society

Athearn

Atlas Model Railroad Company

Bachmann Industries

Backdrop Warehouse

Bar Mills Scale Models

Bearco Marine

Bethlehem Car Works

Big City Hobbies

Bills Train Shop

Blair Line

BLMA Models

Bollinger Edgerly Scale Trains

Bowser Manufacturing

BPH Enterprises

Bragdon Enterprises

Broadway Limited

Caboose Hobbies

Caboose Industries

Canadian Model Trains

Chicagoland Hobbies

Chooch Enterprises

Classic Metal Works

Classic Mint Collectibles

Clover House

Coach Yard

Coffman Graphic
Solutions Co.


Con-Cor International

Cooper & Oshtemo Locomotive Works

Crown Custom Products

Custom Trax

Dallee Electronics

Deluxe Innovations

Des Plaines Hobbies

Digitrax

Doc's Caboose

Doctor Ben's Scale Consortium

Erie Lackawanna Historical Society

Evergreen Hill Designs

Evergreen Scale Models

Evan Designs

Foley Woodworking

Fos Scale Limited

French River Model Works

Friends Of The East Broad Top

GCLaser

George's Trains

Global Outlet Corp

GML Enterprises

Great Scale Model Train Show

Greenberg Shows

Greenway Products

Griffin, Art

Highlands Station

Hobby 411

Hobby Loads

Images Replicas

Im_Ports

International
Hobby Corp.


JJL Models

JL Innovative

JV Models

Karl's Hobbies

Kato U.S.A.

Keller, Allen

Keithco

Key Imports

King Mill Enterprises

Lenz Digital

Loys Toys

M.L.W. Service

Magic Water

MainStreet Heritage Models

M.B. Klein

McHenry Couplers

Mesa Models

Micro-Mark Tools

Micro-Trains Line

Microscale Products

Miniatronics

Mitchell's Family Store

Model Railroad News

Model Railway Post Office

Model Rectifier Corporation

Model Tech
Studios


Monroe Models

Mosteller - Great Decals

Mountain State RR & Logging HS

MTS Imports

Narrow Gauge & Shortline Gazette

National Association of S Gaugers

National Narrow Gauge Convention

National Rails Project

NCE

New Rail Models

NJ International

Northeastern Scale Lumber Co.

Northeastern Scale Models

Northern Pacific Railroad Historical Society

N Scale Architect

OK Streamliners

Old & Weary Car Shop

Original Whistle Stop

Overland Models

PBL

Portland Car & Foundary

Portman Hobby Distributors

Precision Scale Co

Rail Graphics Custom Decals

Rail Shop

Railway And Locomotive Historical Society

Railway Heritage Models

Ragg's To Riches

RamTrack

Rapido Trains

Red Caboose

Ron's Books

RRTrains

Rusty Stump Scale Models

San Juan Car Company

Scalecoat Model Paint

Scale University

Scenic Express

Schrader Enterprises

Sergent Engineering

S Helper Service

Signature Press

SJT Enterprises

Solidesign Decals

Southern Car & Foundry

Southern Pacific Historical Society

Speedwitch Media

State Tool & Die

Sumpter Valley Depot

Sylvan Scale Models

Teenage Association of Model Railroaders

Thinfilm Decals

TK Hobbies

Tomalco Track

Tomar Industries

Tower 55

Toy Train Heaven

TRRA Historical Society

Traction & Trolleys Quarterly

Train World

Trains Unlimited Tours

Traintown of Canada

TrainWeb

Valley Model
Trains


Walthers

Weekend Chief Publishing

Westerfield

Western Scale Models

Woodland Scenics

Ye Olde
Huff N' Puff


Yoder Models

Youth in Model Railroading

Howard Zane

Walthers 52’ Thrall Gondola

 

Wm. K Walthers
5601 West Florist Ave.
Milwaukee, WI 53218
www.walthers.com 

HO Scale
MSRP $19.98
 

The Prototype

In the 1960’s the railroads were actively upgrading their freight car rosters to meet the demands of shippers, to address the changing character of the rail freight business and to counter competition from other modes of transportation.  The steel industry in particular pushed the railroads to introduce gondola cars with higher capacity and higher sides.  The higher sides were needed to achieve the greater capacity, but also to ease load-securing problems associated with earlier low-sided gondola designs.  In the early and mid 60’s the 52’ gondolas were frequently 70-ton capacity cars with 4’ or 4’ 6” sides.  The 1970 Car and Locomotive Cyclopedia note that by that date a significant portion of new gondola construction was 100-ton capacity cars. 

The Thrall Car Manufacturing Co. was a major supplier of the new higher capacity freight cars, and specialized in all-welded construction.  Thrall was a family owned business located in the Chicago area until sold to Trinity Industries in 2001.  The initial Thrall 70-ton gondolas were characterized by welded construction with fish belly sides having 13 or 14 ribs, and could be ordered with a variety of side heights, ends, floors and load restraints to suit customer needs.  In the late 1960’s Thrall introduced 100-ton cars that featured larger side ribs that distinguish them from the earlier 70-ton cars.  Thrall continued to build these cars well into the 1990’s.  They were supplanted by the current production 52’ 6” IL cars that typically have 5’6” sides and a higher 115-ton capacity.  These cars are used by the steel industry for hauling both steel scrap to the mills and finished steel products.  They can also be seen with loads of pulpwood, machinery, aggregates, track materials, etc. 

The Model

The Walthers model is based on the Thrall 100-ton car with 5’ sides having 14-posts.  The specific car reviewed was lettered for the Detroit, Toledo & Ironton car number 9676, Walthers item number 932-40257.  The paint and lettering conform to prototype photos, and are neatly applied and very crisp – all the words in the minute equipment lease stencil can be read with a magnifying glass.  The car comes fully assembled except for the grab irons.  The modeler must drill #80 holes at the locating dimples, install the wire grabs provided in the kit, and paint the grabs in an appropriate color for the car.  (For the DT&I car, the grabs were initially yellow like the ladders, but quickly became black as the cars saw heavy use.)  The www.rr-fallenflags.org web site has a great number of prototype rolling stock photos that can be used to confirm colors for the other road names Walthers offers.


 

Walthers includes a removable interior rack for securing coil steel loads.  The model has abbreviated underbody detail with longitudinal and transverse ribs together with air brake cylinder, triple valve and air reservoir, but no air piping or brake rigging.  Prototype photos show that some of the brake rods are visible below the fishbelly sides, so modelers with eye-level trackage may want to add these details.  The car comes with rigid frame roller bearing trucks with metal RP-25 wheelsets and working knuckle couplers.  The car weighs 2.5 oz., somewhat less than the NMRA recommended 4.75 oz. for a car of this length. However, this is easily remedied by adding any number of different loads.

These widely used cars should be at home on any layout modeling the period from the late 1960’s to the present.  Walthers has announced the following road names for these gondolas as both single cars and two packs: 

932-40250 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Undecorated

932-40251 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Soo Line

932-40252 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Wisconsin Central

932-40253 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Milwaukee Road

932-40254 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Green Bay & Western

932-40255 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Union Pacific(R)

932-40256 - Thrall 53' Gondola - Conrail

932-40257 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola - Detroit, Toledo & Ironton

932-40258 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola - Illinois Terminal

932-40259 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola - Denver & Rio Grande Western

932-40260 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola - Florida East Coast

932-40261 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola - Missouri-Kansas-Texas

932-40262 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola - Wisconsin Central

932-240251 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited-Run Two Pack - Soo Line

932-240252 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited-Run Two Pack - Wisconsin Central

932-240253 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited-Run Two Pack - Milwaukee Road

932-240254 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited-Run Two Pack - Green Bay & Western

932-240255 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited-Run Two Pack - Union Pacific(R)

932-240256 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited-Run Two Pack - Conrail

932-240257 - Thrall 53' 14-Post Gondola Assembled Limited-Run 2-Pack - Detroit, Toledo & Ironton

932-240258 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited Run 2 Pack - Illinois Terminal

932-240259 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited Run 2 Pack - Denver & Rio Grande Western

932-240260 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited Run 2 Pack - Florida East Coast

932-240261 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited Run 2 Pack - Missouri-Kansas-Texas

932-240262 - Thrall 53' Gondola Limited Run 2 Pack - Wisconsin Central

 Reviewed by Gary Quale